Feds applaud B.C. Supreme Court decision against private health care

Vancouver orthopaedic surgeon Brian Day

Opponents have said a two-tier system would favour patients who are wealthy enough to pay for "queue-jumping" private insurance as well as doctors who could bill both the public and private systems. It also stops private clinics from enacting extra patient charges and taking private insurance for necessary medical procedures.

"I think it's fair to say, in this 880-page judgement, the ruling emphasized the strength and the importance of public health care, which is a cornerstone of our identity in British Columbia, a cornerstone of our identity in all of Canada", Dix said. Justice Steeves dismissed the plaintiffs' claims, which aimed to unleash private health care by challenging key principles of the province's publicly-funded system. Day's Cambie Surgeries clinic and other plaintiffs asserted that the rules breach the Charter of Rights when the public system is backlogged with long wait lists, something they said is common. This decision ensures that access to health care will continue to be based on need and not on ability to pay.

However, Steeves ruled the sections of the Medicare Act being challenged are meant to protect the universal public health care system "that ensures access to necessary medical care is based on need, and not on an individual's ability to pay". The Canadian Constitution Foundation, a private registered charity that defends "the constitutional rights and freedoms of Canadians in the courts of law and public opinion", according to their website, announced in a statement on Thursday they are supporting the plaintiffs in Day's case with going forward with an appeal.

Dix said Thursday that a decision on fines will be made after a review of the lengthy ruling. If this chronic underfunding isn't rectified, more challenges will be brought against the Canada Health Act.

Day began his battle a decade ago against the B.C. government.

He opened the Cambie Surgery Centre in 1996, saying he wanted to create more operating-room time for surgeons who couldn't get it in hospitals.

Kangana flight chaos: IndiGo told to act against unruly fliers
A video shared on social media and shot by a passenger on the same flight shows reporters crowding around the actor. The airlines have been told to act against violators or face action.

The Chaoulli case, named after a Quebec doctor barred from setting up a private hospital, dealt exclusively with the province's ban on private health insurance, not the extra-billing question.

The case, filed in 2009, went to trial in B.C. Supreme Court in 2016. "I think the court has made a decision that's harmful to patients".

The society is now calling on the province to commit to patient wait time guarantees, and it's hoping the government will consult with front-line workers on how to improve waits for patients.

"It sets up perverse incentives for doctors", she said, noting physicians are free to opt out of the public system if they choose to practise in private clinics, but not do both.

The recent public health emergency caused by COVID-19 has underscored just how important our public health care system is.

The head of the Canadian Medical Association, which Day led in 2006, agreed with Steeves' ruling that patients should have timely and equitable access to care not based on how much money they have. This decision protects our ability to endure crises and care for one other into the future.

Related News:



Most liked

Newquay: Policeman airlifted to hospital with serious burns after 'attempted murder'
Pc Mares, 51, is now in a stable condition at Derriford Hospital in Plymouth after sustaining life-changing injuries. A man has been charged after a police officer suffered serious burns while helping with an eviction in Newquay .

⚡Jose Mourinho Confident of Tottenham Hotspur Signing a Striker in Transfer Season
'If they get a good player in the past year of his contract, I think they're in a privilege position to do a good deal for them. Jose Mourinho has set Tottenham hard targets for the new season as he hopes to foster an ambitious mentality within his squad.

Former police officers charged in George Floyd death appear in court
They have requested that their cases be moved outside Minneapolis and have filed motions to dismiss the charges. They argued that it would be impossible to receive a fair trial in Minneapolis given all the publicity.

Chelsea's transfer spend demands title challenge from Lampard
Chelsea have been by far the most active team in the transfer market so far, spending almost £250m with more deals on the way. He said: "I didn't come into the job to fight for fourth place or bring academy players in; I came here to win".

Paulette likely to threat Bermuda as a hurricane
The current expectation is Tropical Storm Rene will strengthen enough to be upgraded to hurricane status in a couple of days. The National Hurricane Center is tracking seven systems, with the newest one added at the 8 a.m. update.

Michael Bloomberg Donates $100 Million to Defeat Trump in Florida
Michael Bloomberg speaks by video feed during the 4th and final night of the 2020 Democratic National Convention. In the first moments of his 2016 campaign, he declared that many Mexican immigrants were "rapists".

LA County deputies apparently ambushed in patrol vehicle
The skirmish continued until the suspect was shot twice by deputies and died. "This is just a sober reminder it's a unsafe job. Villanueva expressed his condolences to the families of the officers, adding "Hopefully they can both heal from this".

Two LA sheriff's deputies shot sitting in vehicle in 'unprovoked' attack
Kent Wegener said officers were blanketing the area in search of the suspect seen on the video opening fire with a pistol. The suspect who shot the deputies was - and is still - at large. "It pisses me off, it dismays me at the same time".

Vaccine trials in United Kingdom to resume: AstraZeneca
The vaccine is likely to be made available if positive outcome is reached in the Phase III trials by early next year. Seven out of a total of 135 vaccines have managed to reach the third stage of clinical trials, she said.

Tuscan Grand Prix crash-fest unkind to Kannapolis-based Haas F1 team
Bottas questioned the safety of the current procedures and rules that mean drivers can leave it so late before accelerating. In detailed analysis of the incident on the SkyPad, Anthony Davidson explained: "You have to wait for the guy in front".

Beijing to impose restrictions on all U.S. diplomats
President Donald Trump (R) and his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping inspect the honor guard in Beijing on November 9, 2017. China will take reciprocal measures in response to USA actions".

Weather: This weekend, today is the day to go outside
A chance for light rain showers as early as late morning but the chances for rain grow through the afternoon and evening. Wind will be from the southeast as the high moves through and a weather system for Sunday approaches.

Springsteen on Broadway Star to Release New Album This Fall
Rolling Stone reported that Springsteen said in a statement, 'I love the emotional nature of Letter To You . Letter To You is Springsteen's first time performing with the E Street Band since The River 2016 tour.

Zomato raises Rs. 760 crore from Tiger Global: Details here
Despite the uncertainty in the current market, analysts said that these losses wouldn't impact Zomato's IPO aspirations. The IPO's location is not clear yet, whether it will have its launch in the USA or India .

Vaccine confidence volatile, vulnerable to misinformation, global study finds
The researchers analysed data from 290 nationally representative surveys conducted between September 2015 and December 2019. This, Larson said, was linked to trends in political instability and religious extremism in these countries.