Scientists slam China gene-editing study, warn of freak mutations

Chinese experiment to immunise twins against HIV may have failed, created mutations: Scientists

Scientists say a Chinese researcher's claim to have edited the DNA of the "CRISPR babies" and immunized them from HIV has been "a deliberate falsehood".

Research on the gene-editing experiment involving a pair of twin girls to immunise them against HIV has been published for the first time, and scientists are of the opinion that the study may have created "unintended mutations".

Excerpts from the manuscript were released by MIT Technology Review for the objective of showing how Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui ignored ethical and scientific norms in creating twins Lula and Nana, whose birth late a year ago sent shock waves through the scientific world.

Effective July 2018, access to full reports will only be available with a subscription. It is this gene that Jiankui claimed to have targeted using the powerful editing tool CRISPR.

Fyodor Urnov, a genome-editing scientist on the College of California, Berkeley instructed the MIT Know-how Evaluate: "The declare they've reproduced the prevalent CCR5 variant is a blatant misrepresentation of the particular information and may exclusively be described by one time period: a deliberate falsehood. The statement that embryo editing will help millions is equal parts delusional and outrageous".

Moreover, CRISPR remains an imperfect tool because it can lead to unwanted or "off-target" edits, making its use in humans hugely controversial. However, the search was not comprehensive, and the paper ignores an important point: that any cells taken from early-stage embryos would not actually contribute to the twins' bodies. "It is technically impossible to determine whether an edited embryo 'did not show any off-target mutations.' This is a key problem for the entirety of the embryo-editing field, one that the authors sweep under the rug here".

Dr Urnov called the claim "an egregious misrepresentation of the right records that can, but again, ideal be described as a blatant falsehood".

Body of missing woman found in Outback
For a few days, the group stayed close to the vehicle , surviving on the limited supplies they had packed, McBeath-Riley said. They had used up all their supplies of water, as well as some vodka drinks, biscuits and beef noodles they had in the auto .

The scientists believe that the parents of the twins wanted to partake in this experiment for the wrong reasons.

Their lack of access to any kind of fertility treatment may have motivated them to take part in the experiment despite the huge risks to their children, Jeanne O'Brien, a reproductive endocrinologist at Shady Grove Fertility told the MIT Technology Review.

Scientists noted other potential ethics issues in He's research, observing that Lulu and Nana's parents belonged to a "vulnerable patient group" due to their father being HIV-positive, which carries an intense stigma in China and might have barred the couple from ever receiving fertility treatment otherwise.

The researchers also seem to have made it hard to find the family by omitting the names of the fertility doctors and by stating a false date of birth.

Scientists are now saying that Jiankui's experiment may have failed.

Dr He's manuscript used to be submitted to journals in conjunction with Nature and the Journal of the American Medical Association, nonetheless has no longer been officially published.

Related News:



Most liked

Upgraded indictment 'likely' against Giuliani associates, says prosecutor
Yovanovitch was recalled from her post weeks later amid a smear campaign by Giuliani and others on conservative media outlets. Parnas has indicated that he intends to comply with a subpoena he received from Democrats in the House of Representatives.

Tech sold in Russia required to have Russian apps under law
Those with a foreign agent distinction are subject to additional government scrutiny. Putin blamed Western influence and money for those protests.

Terry Crews criticized the reaction to Gabrielle Union's "AGT" dismissal
Stern said it is "obvious" that the show consistently replaces female judges with younger and more attractive women. Meanwhile, the show's creator and host Simon Cowell , has been severely criticized and blamed for the culture.

Jay-Z’s 50th birthday celebrated with a return to Spotify
After a two-year hiatus, Shawn " Jay Z " Carter's music is back on Spotify and it's just in time for his fiftieth birthday . However, Spotify announced the news by wishing him a Happy Birthday on Twitter earlier today.

Read the legal experts' opening statements before the House Judiciary Committee
Gerhardt said. "Obstruction of justice, I think, is too clear not to include" in impeachment articles, Clyburn said. Democrats say the Republican president misused the power of his office and obstructed Congress' investigation.

Polish, Turkish presidents discuss Baltic states ahead of North Atlantic Treaty Organisation summit
We support productive cooperation with China, which we also consider to be a rising power. The cease-fire is holding very much so and I think people are surprised, ' Trump said.

The Russia-China 'Power of Siberia' Natural Gas Pipeline Officially Begins Service
Its first stop in China is the northeastern city of Heihe in the Heilongjiang Province bordering Russian Federation . The pipeline's capacity could further increase beyond 2024, PetroChina Vice President Ling Xiao said in June.

Crystal Palace 1-0 Bournemouth: Super-sub Jeffrey Schlupp proves the difference
Good evening and welcome to Selhurst Park, where Crystal Palace beat Bournemouth 1-0 to move up to fifth in the Premier League. Substitute Schlupp grabbed the all-important victor in the 76th minute to send Palace to fifth in the standings on 21 points.

SpaceX, NASA gear up for space station resupply launch
Being able to do this 12 hours at a time from the exterior of the ISS will be extremely useful to the team of astronauts. That experiment is part of Anheuser-Busch's effort to make Budweiser "the first beer on Mars", according to Wired .

Australia to face Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, Uruguay in 2020 Copa America
Asian Cup holder Qatar has been drawn in Group B and will face co-hosts Colombia , defending champions Brazil , Ecuador , Peru and Venezuela .

Chris Petersen steps down at Washington, Jimmy Lake named head coach
Jimmy is a great teacher of the game and his track record of developing young men both on and off the field speaks for itself. He left after only one season and eventually wound up on Petersen's staff at Boise State as a defensive backs coach.

Oil rises for a second day as Saudi Arabia pushes supply cut
The remaining shares are allocated for institutional investors, such as banks or sovereign wealth funds. OPEC meets on Thursday in Vienna, with the meeting with its external partners scheduled for Friday.

Google Photos adds in-built conversation feature
The recipient will need a Google account to receive the photos, however, because they'll need to sign-in to view the conversation. Instead, Google notes that this feature wants to relocate sharing to Google Photos rather than using other apps for it.

Protesters call for action after woman gang-raped and killed in India
The burnt body of the veterinary doctor was found at Shadnagar outskirts in Telangana's Ranga Reddy district last week. Police have suspended three officers.

Zuckerberg defends allowing false ads on Facebook, saying company shouldn’t be ‘censoring’
Mark Zuckerberg says people should "judge for themselves" when it comes to political advertising . On Thursday, the Tories rejected a request from the BBC's lawyers to remove the 15-second video.