Journalist blocked on Twitter by Trump talks about winning case against president

The judge concluded that U.S. President Donald Trump

A federal judge in NY ruled Wednesday that President Trump may not block users from following his Twitter account because the social media platform is a "public forum" protected by the First Amendment. "As long as they remain blocked, 'the Individual Plaintiffs can not view the President's tweets; directly reply to these tweets; or use the @realDonaldTrump webpage to view the comment threads associated with the President's tweets while they are logged in to their verified accounts, '" she wrote, quoting from a court document.

U.S. District Court Judge Gregory F. Van Tatenhove wrote that public officials "can choose whom to listen to on those platforms without offending the First Amendment". She rejected the president's defense that the First Amendment didn't apply, and "the President's personal First Amendment interests supersede those of the plaintiffs", the Knight First Amendment Institute and others. "Hope Hicks is also dismissed as a defendant, in light of her resignation as White House Communications Director". They claimed the president uses Twitter as a public forum to share official information in his capacity as president and therefore was violating their right to petition the government by blocking them.

The Department of Justice argued a year ago that users who are not logged into their Twitter accounts can still see the president's tweets online because they are public.

The judge did not issue an order against Trump, and the plaintiffs did not ask for one.

She wrote that "because all government officials are presumed to follow the law once the judiciary has said what the law is, we must assume that the President [and his social media director] will remedy the blocking we have held to be unconstitutional".

"We respectfully disagree with the court's decision and are considering our next steps", spokeswoman Kerri Kupec said in an emailed statement. Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with an account altogether. In last year's ruling about Facebook blocking, the judge held that public officials could do a certain amount of content moderation, provided that it was done in a content-neutral manner.

Ahead of driving ban lift, Saudi women's rights activists arrested
Some Saudi Arabian clubs are now experiencing financial problems that require immediate and urgent intervention. Activists had said al-Mana previously suffered a stroke and were concerned for her health while under arrest.

While this lawsuit targets Trump's behavior, Buchwald's ruling extends to all public officials - and could likely spark a wave of similar litigation against other block-happy government employees.

Genevieve Lakier, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School who helped write a friend-of-the-court brief filed by First Amendment scholars, welcomed Wednesday's decision.

The blocked: Along with Cohen, several other Twitter users have accused Trump of blocking them on Twitter. The group argued that failing to recognize Trump's Twitter feed as a public forum would "threaten critical First Amendment values".

Twitter is a social media platform with more than 300 million active users worldwide, including some 70 million in the United States.

Per the court decision, Trump is legally obligated to immediately unblock anyone that he's blocked, even on his personal account, as soon as possible.

The government did not dispute that Mr. Trump blocked people because of those kinds of antagonistic tweets. And that, ruled Naomi Buchwald, a New York Federal judge, raises a constitutional problem.

Related News:



Most liked

Lee Westwood grabs chance to be Ryder Cup vice-captain
McDowell is a two-time victor of the French Open at Le Golf National, site of the Ryder Cup. The tournament kicks off on Friday 28th September in Le Golf National in Paris.

Teen suspect charged as adult after running down, killing US police officer
The department did not say whether the three played any role in the officer's death and have not released their identities. Harris was apprehended shortly after abandoning the Jeep, which was stolen May 18 in Baltimore, not far away, Bickel said.

Battlefield V Ditches the Premium Pass, Launches in October
Along with War Stories and Combined Arms, the traditional multiplayer is also getting a big bump in Grand Operations. Dice mentions there is a renewed movement system in Battlefield V with new animations, little was shared about it.

Trump Administration Considering 25 Percent Tariffs on Imported Vehicles
It is the same method Trump usedearlier this year to slap a 25% tariff on imported steel and a 10% tariff on imported aluminum. Until then, the United States had pursued only two such investigations since joining the World Trade Organization in 1995.

Find out which Marks and Spencer stores could close in East Anglia
At the time M&S said it would axe about 60 stores across the United Kingdom - possibly affecting around 2,000 jobs. The tranche of closures affect Clothing & Home stores that have been underperforming for several years.

NFL Adopts New Anthem Policy to Quell Player Protests
Giants co-owner John Mara is the chairman of the NFL Management Council Executive Committee and directly tied into the new policy. The policy comes after repeated protests from players over the last two seasons. "One of those values is freedom of expression".

Astros pay tribute in 'We Play For Santa Fe' shirts
He said he had asked police to allow him to go into the school during the standoff so his son could kill him instead of students. Gillard says she saw Garcia move to help two others get off the floor before she fled.

Jared Kushner finally gets permanent security clearance
Among other benefits he will have restored is access to the President's Daily Brief, a morning summary of global intelligence. Lowell said Kushner answered all questions and "is looking forward to continuing the work the president has asked him to do".

Mark Zuckerberg's European Union parliament meeting was spectacularly awkward
British parliamentarian Damian Collins called the meeting a "missed opportunity" and renewed his call for Mr. We are constantly needing to evolve our service in order to stay relevant and serve people well.

Trump Demands Review Of Russia Investigation Surveillance Tactics
Giuliania told the AP that the probe's conclusion would be the "culmination of the investigation into the president". However, his lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, said neither he nor the president knows for sure if it really happened.

'American Idol' Finale 2018: And the Winner Is Maddie Poppe
I don't doubt for a minute that it's going to do great numbers within my fan base. "Getting to stand by her was the best". But final two contestants Caleb Lee Hutchinson , 18, and Maddie Poppe , 20, were not just rivals - they were dating.

Iran to keep forces in Syria upon Assad's request
In 2016, government forces enjoyed their biggest victory, capturing neighborhoods in Aleppo that rebels had controlled for years. He stressed that those who have entered the Syria without the permission of its government should leave.

National Basketball Association roundup: Iguodala doubtful for Game 4
The 41-point margin of defeat was the largest in the Rockets' postseason history. In 13 games, he's averaging 7.9 points, 4.9 rebounds and 3.1 assists.

Pioneering journalist Tom Wolfe has died at the age of 88
This post has been corrected to reflect that Wolfe was 88 when he died , not 87. Wolfe slammed both Charles Darwin and linguist Noam Chomsky in the book.

5-Star, League want European Central Bank to forgive €250 billion of Italy debt
So far, ambitious plans from French President Emmanuel Macron have met with a cool reception in Berlin. The ECB holds a total of about 2.4 trillion euros of government bonds under the QE program.